M. Hrushevskyi's scientific and publicistic activities (1907-1914): problem in Ukrainian historiography of the 20th century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21847/1728-9343.2014.4(130).26724Keywords:
M.Hrushevskyi studies, scientific and publicistic studios, historiographical researchAbstract
The article highlights particular issues of the research of M.Hrushevskyi's scientific and publicistic activities in the period (1907-1914) carried out by researchers of Ukrainian historiography. The historians considered a number of issues connected with the increase in his activities in the context of peculiarities of the historiographical condition in those times. The historiographical analysis has made it possible to determine the extent of the research of M.Hrushevskyi's scientific and publicistic activities in that period of his life carried out by the Ukrainian scientists and to broaden the scope of issues of further development of Hrushevskyi studies.
1907 - 1914 was a hard and controversial period in the Ukrainian history but M.Hrushevskyi was preoccupied with work in order to help the national movement achieve its goal - autonomy of Ukraine. The historian published such scientific works as "History of Ukraine-Rus" - vol. 6 and 7, "History of the Ukrainian Cossacks", "Illustrated History of Ukraine" and others; publicistic works concerned with vital political issues of those times in such journals as "Movement of the Ukrainian political and social thought in the 19th century", "From the traveling wave", "Liberation of Russia and the Ukrainian issue", "Our policy" and others. That is why the aforementioned period of M.Hrushevskyi's activities was distinguished by fruitful work in the fields of science and publicistic writing. In the publicistic studios of those times the historian was trying to explain the socio-political situation Ukraine was being faced by and to give good advice on how to overcome that hard condition. In this context, the analysis of the outstanding historian's legacy carried out by the researchers of Ukrainian historiography makes the circle of blank spaces in M.Hrushevskyi studies narrower in particular and sets new objectives that boost further development of the Ukrainian historical science as a whole.
The analysis of the research carried out by historians and publicistic writers has made it possible to realize the scientists' interest in this problem. M.Hrushevskyi's contemporaries (M.Gechter, S.Iefremov, V.Doroshenko, V.Gerasymchuk and V.Picheta) paid their highest compliments to his scientific and publicistic activities, acknowledging his positive understanding of the socio-political processes of those times along with his experience of a historian and a publicistic writer. They also acknowledged the influence of scientific and publicistic activities on the cultural and spiritual level of all the groups of the population from intelligentsia to ordinary people.
The evaluations of that period of M.Hrushevskyi's activities presented by Soviet historians were ambiguous. Besides an attempt was made to analyze his scientific and publicistic activities. On the other hand, there were some accusations of negative treatment of Marxist-Leninist methodology.
The historian's activities were examined in other aspects by emigrants, such as D.Doroshenko, O.Ogloblyn, N.Polonska-Vasylenko and O.Pritsak. They ascertained that those activities had an influence on the union of the two parts of Ukraine. In this context, they emphasized the great role of the scientific and organizational activities and acknowledged the scientist's high level of publicistic work as well as his incessant work at "History of Ukraine-Rus" from the point of view of a historian and a sociologist.
The historiographical analysis has revealed various aspects in the highlight of this problem the historians were trying to solve and set a number of objectives for the future.References
Винар Л. Сучасний стан грушевськознавства (генеза, структура, завдання) / Л. Винар // Пам'ять століть. - 1996. - № 2. - С. 62-70.
Галій М. Від видавництва // Грушевський М. Вибрані праці видано з нагоди 25-річчя з дня його смерті (1934-1959) / М. Галій. - Нью-Йорк : Гол. Управи ОУРДП в США, 1960. - С. 7-30.
Герасимчук В. Михайло Грушевський як історіограф України / В. Герасимчук // Записки наукового товариства ім. Шевченка. - Львів, 1922. - Т. CXXXIII. - С. 1-26.
Гехтер М. Спогади М. Гехтера про перебування в Києві в 1906-1914 рр. Листи М. Гехтера до М. Грушевського / М. Гехтер ; [упор. І. Ткаченко]. - К. : НАН України. Ін-т укр. археографії та джерелознавства ім. М. С. Грушевського, 2005. - 62 с.
Гирич І. Професор Любомир Винар і сучасне грушевськознавство / І. Гирич // Винар Л. Грушевськознавство: Ґенеза і іст. розвиток / Л. Винар. - К., 1999. - С. 119-126.
Дорошенко В. Михайло Грушевський: Культурно-національний рух на Україні / В. Дорошенко // РНВ. - 1912. - С. 297-298.
Дорошенко Д. Михайло Грушевський / Д. Дорошенко, О. Оглоблин // Енциклопедія українознавства. Загальна частина. Перевидання в Україні. - К., 1995. - 800 с.
Єфремов С. На сторожі національної гідності. До характеристики публіцистичної діяльності проф. М. С. Грушевського / С. Єфремов // Український історик. Журнал українського історичного Товариства. - Нью-Йорк, Торонто, Київ, Львів, Мюнхен, 1995. - № 124-127. - С. 167-179.
Заброварний С. Економічні погляди Михайла Грушевського / С. Заброварний // Український історичний збірник. - К., 2008. - Вип. 11. - С. 352-368.
Корчмарчик Б. Концепція Михайла Грушевського і наші сучасні підручники історії України / Б. Корчмарчик // Михайло Грушевський. Збірник наукових праць і матеріалів Міжнародної ювілейної конференції, присвяченої 125-й річниці від дня народження Михайла Грушевського. - Львів : НТШ, 1994. - С. 359-381.
Крип'якевич І. Михайло Грушевський. Життя й діяльність / І. Крип'якевич // Великий українець: Матеріали з життя та діяльності М. С. Грушевського / [упоряд., підгот. текстів та фотоматеріалів, комент., приміт. А. П. Демиденка ; вступ. слово Л. М. Кравчука ; післямова Ф. П. Шевченка]. - К. : Веселка, 1992. - С. 448-483.
Оглоблин О. Михайло Сергієвич Грушевський (1866-1934) / О. Оглоблин // Український історик. - 1966. - № 1-2. - С. 6-14.
Оглоблин О. Грушевський М. / О. Оглоблин // Енциклопедія Українознавства. - Т. 2. Перевидання в Україні. - К. : Глобус, 1994. - С. 453-455.
Отзыв о Записке Чихачева в департаменте народного просвещения; Министерство Народного просвещения. Попечителя Киевского учебного округа канцелярия (8 февраля 1915 г.) // Российский государственный исторический архив. - Ф. 733. - Оп. 201. - Д. 503.
Пичета В. Введение в русскую историю (Источники и историография) / В. Пичета. - М., 1922. - 209 с.
Пріцак О. Історіософія Михайла Грушевського / О. Пріцак // Грушевський М. Історія України-Руси : в 11 т., 12 кн. / [редкол.: П. С. Сохань (голова) та ін.]. - К. : Наук. думка, 1991. - Т. 1. - С. XL-LXXIII.
Полонська-Василенко Н. Історія України / Н. Полонська-Василенко. - Т. 2. - К. : Либідь, 1992. - 608 с.
Произведения М. Грушевского "Про старі часи на Україні", изъято в июне 1907 г. При обыске у дворянки М. Харченко в Киеве // Центральный государственный исторический архив Украины. - Ф. Киевская судебная палата, № 318. - Оп. 1. - Ед. хр. 1817. - Л. 143, 216.
Сарбей В. До питання про наукову спадщину М. С. Грушевського / В. Сарбей // Український історичний журнал. - 1989. - № 10. - С. 114-126.
REFERENCES
Vynar L. (1996), Current status hrushevskoznavstva (genesis, structure, tasks), Pamiat stolit [Memory centuries], № 2, pp. 62-70 (ukr).
Halii M. (1960), From the publisher, Hrushevskyi M. Selected works issued on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of his death (1934-1959), New York, pp. 7-30 (ukr).
Herasymchuk W. (1922), Mykhailo Hrushevskyi as historiographer of Ukraine, Notes of Shevchenko Scientific Society, Lviv, Vol. CXXXIII, pp. 1-26 (ukr).
Hekhter M. (2005), Memoirs of M. Hekhter's to staying in Kyiv in 1906-1914 years. Letters of M. Hekhter's to M. Hrushevskyi, Kyiv, 62 p. (ukr).
Hyrych I. (1999), Professor Liubomyr Vynar and modern hrushevskoznavstvo, in Vynar L. Hrushevskoznavstvo: Genesis and Historical Development, Kyiv, pp. 119-126 (ukr).
Doroshenko V. (1912), Mykhailo Hrushevskyi: Cultural and national movement in Ukraine, RNV, pp. 297-298 (ukr).
Doroshenko D., Ohloblyn O. (1995), Mykhailo Hrushevskyi, Encyclopedia of Ukrainian studies. General part. Reissue in Ukraine, Kyiv, 800 p. (ukr).
Yefremov S. (1995), On guard national dignity. A Characterization of journalistic activities prof. M.Hrushevskyi, Ukrainian historian. Ukrainian Journal of the Historical Society, New York, Toronto, Kyiv, Lviv, Munich, № 124-127, pp. 167-179 (ukr).
Zabrovarnyi S. (2008), Economic views of M. Hrushevskyi's, Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zbirnyk [Ukrainian Historical Collection], Kyiv, Vol. 11, pp. 352-368 (ukr).
Korchmarchyk B. (1994), Concept of M. Hrushevskyi's and our modern history textbooks Ukraine, Scientific Papers and materials of International Jubilee Conference devoted to the 125th anniversary of the birth of M. Hrushevskyi's, Shevchenko Scientific Society, Lviv, pp. 359-381 (ukr).
Krypiakevych I. (1992), Mykhailo Hrushevskyi. The life and activity, in Demydenko A. P. (compiler), Great Ukrainian: Proceedings of the life and activity of M. Hrushevskyi's, Kyiv, pp. 448-483 (ukr).
Ohloblyn O. (1966), Mykhailo Serhiievych Hrushevskyi (1866-1934), Ukrainskyi istoryk [Ukrainian historian], № 1-2, pp. 6-14 (ukr).
Ohloblyn O. (1994), Hrushevskyi М., Encyclopedia of Ukrainian studies. General part. Reissue in Ukraine, Кyiv, Vol. 2, pp. 453-455 (ukr).
Russian State Historical Archive, fond 733, opis 201, delo 503 (rus).
Picheta V. (1922), Introduction to Russian history (Sources and Historiography), Moscow, 209 p. (rus).
Pritsak O. (1991), Historiosophy of M. Hrushevskyi's, Hrushevskyi М. History of Ukraine-Rus, in 11 volumes, 12 books, Naukova dumka, Kyiv, Vol. 1. - pp. XL-LXXIII (ukr).
Polonska-Vasylenko N. (1992), History of Ukraine, Vol. 2, Kyiv, 608 p. (ukr).
Central State Historical Archives of Ukraine, fond 318, opis 1, ed. khr. 1817, list 143, 216 (rus).
Sarbei V. (1989), On the question of scientific legacy of M. Hrushevskyi's, Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal [Ukrainian Historical Journal], № 10, pp. 114-126 (ukr).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2014 Natalia Romantsova
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
1. Authors bear responsibility for the accuracy of facts, quotations, numbers and names used.
2. Manuscripts are not sent back.
3. The publisher does not always agree with the authors' opinion.
4. The authors reserve the right to authorship of the work and pass the first publication right of this work to the journal under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License, which allows others to freely distribute the published research with the obligatory reference to the authors of the original work and the first publication of the work in this journal.
5. The authors have the right to conclude separate supplement agreements that relate to non-exclusive work distribution in the form in which it has been published by the journal (for example, to upload the work to the online storage of the journal or publish it as part of a monograph), provided that the reference to the first publication of the work in this journal is included.