DOI: https://doi.org/10.21847/1728-9343.2017.1(147).97561

Conceptualization of subject in Heidegger and Badiou: a search for common grounds

Viacheslav Stepanov, Iryna Novychenko

Abstract


Heidegger and Badiou are not likely to be received as philosophical figures inheriting much in common. The only obvious ground which backs both thinkers is that of ontology as primary focus of their intellectual endeavors. However, this is divergence between their philosophies what makes an attempt to reveal some other conceptual foundations their doctrines have in common so important for a historian of the recent transformations in philosophy. The concept of subject looks as an indicator of differences between Heidegger and Badiou, since Heideggerian destruction of the metaphysics of subject is opposed by positive and affirmative indoctrination of subject developed by Badiou. Affirmative concept of the subject implies certain references to Heidegger's negative hermeneutics of the Modern subjectivity where it says about reactionary subject or dark subject. As we see Badiou skillfully attunes his conception to the profound destructivity of Heidegger's negation of subject. What these two thinkers share is certainly the need for a middle term between totality and unifying force of being and particularity and contingency of the individual human life, which would be efficient in denoting the very transition of the particular into the common. The early Heidegger of decisive Dasein can be regarded as a forerunner of the Maoist revolutionary subject of Badiou, with its prophecy of becoming a historical driving force and gathering the strength of the particular around a traumatic Event. For both Heidegger and Badiou the "movement" of truth (for Heidegger - a permanent projection of Dasein's Being in the mode of authenticity) proceeds trough a series of choices which cannot be governed by a law or "an algorithm." The indiscernible truth forces a subject to permanently find him/herself amid the "undecidable." The procedure of fidelity traverses the existent knowledge. One can scarcely know (due to a sort of epistemic technology) whether an event has taken place, one can rather bet upon its truth. For both philosophers the concept of truth is indissolubly connected with the problems of ethics (ontologically understood). Heidegger points to the "most primordial truth," which is the "truth of existence." Abiding in this truth, Dasein discloses itself to itself and discovers its ownmost potentiality-for-Being.


Keywords


subject; Dasein; concept; ontology; man; subjectity

References


Heidegger, M. (1977), Sein und Zeit, Vittorio Klostermann, Frankfurt am Main, 600 S.

Heidegger, M. (1976), Wegmarken, Vittorio Klostermann, Frankfurt am Main, 202 S.

Badiou, A. (2009), Theory of the subject, Continuum, London, New York, 367 p.

Badiou, A. (2005), Being and Event, Comtinuum, New York, 526 p.

Badiou, A. (2009), Logics of worlds, Continuum, London, 617 p.

Harman, G. (2012), Badiou’s relation to Heidegger in Theory of Subject. In: Badiou and philosophy, Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh, pp. 225-243.

Hunter, I. (2016), Heideggerian mathematics: Badiou’s Being and Event, Representations, Vol. 134 , No. 1, Pp. 116-156. DOI: 10.1525/rep.2016.134.1.116

Cherniakov, A. (2010), Truth and infinity in Heidegger and Badiou, available at: http://artesliberales.spbu.ru/events/afisha/doklady-konferencii-abpolitika-edinogo.-predely-fragmentacii-i-usloviya-vozmozhnoi-solidarnostibb/Aleksei%20CHernyakov.pdf

Skyrtach, V. (2014), Transformation of the subject in the clinical discourse of the 20th century philosophy, LANDON-XXI, Donetsk, 274 p.

Karpenko, A. (2013), The category of subject in Martin Heidegger’s philosophy: exposition of the problem, Scientific Notes. Series: Philosophy, Vol. 14, pp. 111-114.

Karpenko A. (2013), Alain Badiou’s ontology of subject, in: Novikov B. (ed). Marxism and the present: polit-economical, philosophical and sociological dimensions of the global crisis, NTUU “KPI”, Kyiv, pp. 90-91.


GOST Style Citations


1. Heidegger М. Gesamtausgabe Abt. 1. Veröffentlichte Schriften 1914-1970 Bd 2 Sein und Zeit / Martin Heidegger. - Fr. a. M. : Vittorio Klostermann, 1977. - 600 S.

 

2. Heidegger M. Gesamtausgabe Abt. 1 Veröffentlichte Schriften 1914-1970 Bd 9. Wegmarken / Martin Heidegger. - Fr. a. M. : Vittorio Klostermann, 1976. - 202 S.

 

3. Badiou A. Theory of the subject / Alain Badiou ; [tr. by Bruno Bosteels]. - London, New York : Continuum, 2009. - 367 p.

 

4. Badiou A. Being and event / Alain Badiou ; [tr. by Oliver Feltham]. - London, New York : Continuum, 2005. - 526 p.

 

5. Badiou A. Logics of worlds: Being and event, 2 / Alain Badiou ; [tr. by Alberto Toscano]. - London, New York : Continuum, 2009. - 617 p.

 

6. Harman G. Badiou's relation to Heidegger in Theory of Subject / Graham Harman // Badiou and philosophy / [ed. by Sean Bowden and Simon Duffy]. - Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press, 2012. - P. 225-243.

 

7. Hunter I. Heideggerian mathematics: Badiou's Being and Event / Ian Hunter // Representations. - 2016. - Vol. 134 , No. 1. - Pp. 116-156. DOI: 10.1525/rep.2016.134.1.116

 

8. Черняков А. Истина и бесконечность у Хайдеггера и Бадью [Електронний ресурс] / Алексей Черняков. - Режим доступу : http://artesliberales.spbu.ru/events/afisha/doklady-konferencii-abpolitika-edinogo.-predely-fragmentacii-i-usloviya-vozmozhnoi-solidarnostibb/Aleksei%20CHernyakov.pdf

 

9. Скиртач В. Трансформація суб'єкта в клінічному дискурсі філософствування ХХ століття / Віолета Скиртач. - Донецьк : ЛАНДОН-ХХІ, 2014. - 274 с.

 

10. Карпенко А. Категорія суб'єкта у філософії Мартіна Гайдеггера: постановка проблеми / А. Карпенко // Наукові записки. Серія "Філософія". - Острог : Вид-во Національного ун-ту "Острозька академія", 2013. - Вип. 14. - С. 111-114.

 

11. Карпенко А. О Онтологія суб'єкта Алена Бадью / А. Карпенко // Марксизм і сучасність: Політекономічний, філософський та соціологічний виміри глобальної кризи : матеріали ІV Міжнародної наук.-практ. конф. з нагоди 100-річчя виходу книги Рози Люксембург "Накопичення капіталу" (21-22 листопада 2013 р., м. Київ, Україна) / [уклад.: Новіков Б. В., Піхорович В. Д., Дерев'янко А. В. - К. : НТУУ "КПІ", 2013. - C. 90-91.







Copyright (c) 2017 Viacheslav Stepanov, Iryna Novychenko

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

ISSN 1728-9343 (Print)

ISSN 2411-3093 (Online)