B. Chicherin's and V. Soloviyov's philosophical and legal rationale of justice

Authors

  • Oleksandr Kovnerov Donbas State Pedagogical University, Sloviansk

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21847/1728-9343.2013.5(125).19071

Keywords:

justice, law, morals, truth, equality, freedom, good, evil, love

Abstract

The paper examines the issue of justice in the Russian philosophical tradition of the late 19th - early 20th centuries in the context of a philosophical and legal rationale of this category, offered by the famous Russian philosophers Boris Chicherin and Vladimir Soloviyov.

An analysis of Boris Chicherin's works "Philosophy of Law", "Course of State Science" and "Philosophical Issues" afforded ground for concluding that the thinker deduced justice from the idea of freedom and defined it as a balance of compulsory (state) and voluntary (moral) laws. Keeping such a balance is possible only within human unions which supreme rule is adherence to truth i.e. everyone shall get what belongs to him. Requirements of justice also include respect for someone else's rights and minority rights whereas achievement of general welfare is considered by the philosopher as its supreme goal.

Views of Vladimir Soloviyov were explored through analyzing his works "Justification of Good" and "Right and Morals". Justice is among the central concepts of his philosophical conception "Ethics of Universal Unity" and is defined as common equality before the law, the supreme ideal, the good i.e. the only righteous and true life journey. The good as it is reveals to a man his meaning of life through the categories of truth and love. Justice as law of truth destines to each his own whereas justice as law of love shows a man the necessity of sacrifice for his neighbor.

Discussion between these philosophers subsequently governed the extent of creative perception of philosophical and legal issues related to the balance of law and morals, individual freedom and equality.

Author Biography

Oleksandr Kovnerov, Donbas State Pedagogical University, Sloviansk

Assistant Lecturer of the Philosophical, Socio-Political and Legal Sciences Department

References

Чичерин Б. Н. Философия права / Б. Н. Чичерин - СПб. : Наука, 1998. - 654 с.

Чичерин Б. Н. Курс государственной науки / Б. Н. Чичерин - М., 1896. - Ч. 2. - С. 424.

Чичерин Б Н. Вопросы философии / Б. Н. Чичерин. - М., 1904.

Кацапова И. А. История и современность: о дискуссии между Б. Чичериным и В. С. Соловьевым / И. А. Кацапова // Философские науки. - 2012. - № 3. - С. 41-51.

Гурвич Г. Д. Два величайших русских философа права: Борис Чичерин и Владимир Соловьев [Електронний ресурс] / Г. Д. Гурвич. - Режим доступу : http // law. edu. Ru / magazine / article.asp?mag1D = 5 &magnum = 4 &ma.

Соловьев В. Оправдание добра / В. Соловьев // Собр. соч. - Т. 7. - С. 211-487.

Соловьев В. Право и нравственность / В. Соловьев // Собр. соч. - Т. 7.

Чичерин Б. Н. Вопросы политики / Б. Чичерин. - 2-е изд. - М., 1906. - С. 114.

REFERENCES

Chicherin B.N. (1998), Philosophy of Law, Nauka, Sanct-Peterburg, 654 p.

Chicherin B. N. (1896), The course of the state of science, ch. 2, Moskow, p. 424.

Chicherin B.N. (1904), Problems of Philosophy, Moskow.

Katsapova I. A. (2012), Philosophy of Science, 3, pp. 41-51.

Gurvich G. D. Two great Russian philosopher of law: Boris Chicherin and Vladimir Solovyov, available at: http // law. edu. Ru / magazine / article.asp?mag1D = 5 &magnum = 4 &ma.

Soloviev V. (1914), Justification of the Good, Collected Works, Vol.7, pp. 211-487.

Soloviev V. (1914), Law and Morality, Collected Works, Vol. 7.

Chicherin B.N. (1906), Policy issues, Moskow, p. 114.

Published

2013-11-20

Issue

Section

Philosophy